Because Nobody Should Have to Wait for Their Toast
When you’ve got hungry mouths in the morning — whether it’s kids, partners, roommates, or your own ravenous self — a 2-slice toaster just won’t cut it. Standing in line to toast bread one pair at a time? That’s a surefire way to ruin the vibe before coffee even hits.
That’s where 4-slice retro toasters come in. They’re bigger, bolder, and built for efficiency — without sacrificing the aesthetic. We’ve tested the ones that actually perform under pressure and look like they belong in a Wes Anderson movie.
Here’s our shortlist of the best 4-slice retro toasters for big families, brunchers, and multitasking toast lovers.
1. Smeg 50s Retro Style 4-Slice Toaster
Price: ~240$ (Worth it if you want to flex)
Why It Rocks:
This one’s a showstopper. Gorgeous curved design, premium feel, and dual independent controls — meaning you can toast at two different settings at once. It’s expensive, yes, but it screams class and lasts forever. If you want the Rolex of retro toasters, this is it.
2. Keenstone Retro 4-Slice Toaster
Price: ~$60
Why It Rocks:
A budget-friendly family toaster that doesn’t look cheap. The pastel color range, rounded body, and shiny knobs make it a visual treat. More importantly, it browns evenly and has wide enough slots for bagels, thick slices, and Texas toast. Plus, it doesn’t feel like a downgrade even next to premium brands.
3. Buydeem DT640 Retro 4-Slice Toaster
Price: ~$70
Why It Rocks:
A hidden gem. This toaster doesn’t get enough hype, but it’s perfect for families. Dual control panels let two people use it at the same time — no fighting over settings. Solid construction, satisfying knob feel, and a muted retro finish that adds warmth to any kitchen.
4. Cuisinart Classic Retro 4-Slice Toaster
Price: ~$69
Why It Rocks:
Blends retro with pro-level reliability. It has all the functions you expect: bagel, reheat, defrost, plus high-lift levers for small slices. The chrome-and-color combo design hits that vintage sweet spot without being over-the-top.
What to Look for in a 4-Slice Retro Toaster
Big families need more than just more slots. Go for a toaster with:
- Dual controls — so you can toast different breads or settings at once.
- Extra-wide slots — especially if your crew loves bagels or artisan bread.
- High wattage — you don’t want to wait forever.
- Crumb trays that slide out easily — kids = mess. You’ll thank yourself later.
Final Slice
A 4-slice retro toaster is the secret weapon for family breakfast chaos. It saves time, ends toast wars, and looks amazing doing it. Whether you want a budget-friendly buy or a luxury piece of retro kitchen art, the picks above deliver form and function.
Need help deciding which one’s right for you? Check out our Buyer’s Guide for everything you should consider before buying a toaster that does it all.